So Cody and Cordelia are having a bit of a rough patch. (For the last three years, you say? Well, yes.) They are two of the loveliest children ever -- even if one is possibly a sociopath -- but they are utterly hateful to each other right now. Also, they've started saying all that stuff that children just somehow learn, in that tone of voice- - you know the one I mean: "It's not fair! She did it first! It wasn't me! It's not fair!"
This concerns me, for many reasons. But so far, no amount of sternness or nagging or reminding or scolding or reasoning has made a dent in their behavior. So we're doing what all diligent parents do: switching from threats to bribery.
In fairness, the technical term is "positive discipline." And some doctors came up with it, so how bad can it be? The idea is that instead of nagging a child every time they do the same damn wrong thing, you try to make note of the times they get it right, and gradually reinforce the behavior until it becomes the norm.
This takes more patience than you might imagine. Because really, you want to shout, "I don't care who did it first!" Mostly, you do shout that. If you're me. Or, if you're really lofty, "Oh, it's more than fair" in a snide voice, which, if you're really honest, you know preschoolers don't really deserve. And it doesn't actually make you feel better. Or if you're just really on a parenting roll, "I'm not interested -- WORK IT OUT! AND BE NICE TO EACH OTHER, FOR CRYING OUT LOUD!" And then, growing louder and louder, you scream, "...AND STOP SHOUTING!"
It's true that doing the same thing over and over again and expecting--longing for--a different result is the definition of insanity. But it's also the definition of parenthood.
I know they are not unkind children. They're just unkind to each other. And we have a very, very low tolerance for that...especially because it makes me, in turn, respond unkindly. It's a vicious cycle, you see. So like all vicious cycles, it requires the intervention of Art.
Behold the Kindness Chart. I actually thought of this myself, which I hope earns me back a few of the points I've lost by screaming at them to stop screaming. The idea is that with each act of kindness they perform, they earn a "kindness star." After a designated amount of stars (we'll start slow, say, 5) they earn a reward. It might be ice cream, an extra-long bubble bath, a candlelight dinner, movie night, extra stories, a trip to the spray ground, Five Guys...whatever. We're hoping they come to associate positive, happy, peaceful times with their kind behavior, and then -- like M&Ms and potty training -- they won't need to earn the stars anymore. They'll just be nice.
So I got crafty. Here's the chart. Notice that it offers the possibility of healthy competition. They'll stick their stars on their side and can see how they stack up against each other. Here is it on day one, before we've started the new approach...I wanted to take a picture of my handiwork before it became plastered with the evidence of their loving hearts.
Here's day two:
Here's day three:
As you can see, we have some work to do.
Sigh.